YOU CAN'T PLAY 20 QUESTIONS WITH NATURE AND WIN
ALLEN NEWELL
Allen Newell in his 1973 commentary on the Visual Information Processing symposium held at Carnegie University appreciates the work been done in the field of experimental psychology. He noted that the current style of research in psychology is steeped in phenomena whose realities are investigated by the construction, refutation and or support of various opposing binaries but then, they are at the low level and middle level, that keeps adding to an unending cycle of clarifying experiments, but the “questions never seem to be really answered, the strategy does not seem to work” (p.8).
In
getting round to the unification of patterns of research, he noted the
programmability nature of behavior and in order to be successful at it, the
symbolic formula used in information psychology could be employed to predict a
subject, which are; “his goals”, “the structure of the task environment” and “the
invariant structure of his processing mechanisms”. The method the subject is
using in performing experimental tasks should be known, meanwhile, not averaging
over methods. His concern being the effect of such experimental result on the field
of psychology, to him results “should not be permitted unless it can
successfully challenge (or be shown to be consistent with) a substantial part
of the total existing pattern” (p.17).
His
prognosis to the ailing difficulties in the field is to “discover that
structure which is fixed and invariant so that we can theoretically infer the
method” (p.14) by the means of a “control structure” (p.15) in having (1) develop
“complete processing models”, (2) “analyze a complex task completely” to encourage
coherence between studies and (3) have “one program for many tasks” in order to
integrate the diverse collection of small experimental tasks.
Reference
Newell, A. (1973). You can’t
play 20 questions with nature and win: Projective comments on the papers of this
symposium. In W. G. Chase (ed.), Visual Information Processing, New York:
Academic Press.
This is a difficult article, but you have done an excellent job of outlining some of the key points!
ReplyDelete